Well, it is time to make some lemonade.
I’m going to turn this gripe into something more productive.
Let me just start by saying that I am tired of the term “Android Ecosystem”. This, of course, is in reference to the massive store of apps available on the internet droid-based phones that are supposed to be “competing” with one another for supremacy of the mobile-world.
The term has been thrown around for several years now, which to an ecologist and evolutionary theorist has been a troubling few years.
My grief stems from the simple premise that the massive array of apps is not an ecosystem even though its progenitors continuously promote the changing face of “the android ecosystem”.
An ecosystem is defined in many ways, but basically it is a description of everything alive and non-living within an area, and how the living organisms use/exploit energy and nutrients amongst one another. The term was coined in the 1930’s to relate how materials moved between different organisms and further expanded by other biologists to focus largely on energy flow through trophic levels (levels of food consumption such as plants, plant-eater, carnivore, etc.).
Interactions within biologic ecosystems are very dynamic with animals predating on others, having sex, fighting one another, and most importantly, obtaining energy from the sun. That is the driving force of ecosystems. As mentioned on previous posts, without the energy of the sun being internalized by plants in the form of sugar, ecosystems would not be able to function. Throughout time these interactions change as the external environment and climate alter. These changes ultimately will allow organisms to evolve into different species or go extinct, opening up new areas in the ecosystem for other species to exploit the system’s energy.
How does this relate the android ecosystem? There are several things that are similar between the android app mass and ecosystems: 1) They both contain a plethora of species; 2) Both are changing over time; 3) most importantly, both are Non-Equilibrium Thermodynamic System or NETS.
NETS are organized systems that maintain their structure solely by the influx and flow of “energy”. The quotation marks are used because, despite the use of electricity as an actual energy source, the Android Play Store is not maintained by the flow of electrons across gradients, but instead is kept alive by the consumers downloading applications for their phone. If people stop downloading apps for their droid phones the entire system will collapse. With an ecosystem, the structure of the organisms is maintained by the energy from the sun. Plants harness the sun to grow, making their structures larger and reproducing. Other organisms eat plants or decomposing food to obtain the remaining energy to grow their bodies and reproduce. So the system continues so long as there is energy to help the organisms stay alive. NETS are found in many other places in our world and studying them has been a little hobby of mine, so there will be more written in the future.
How are real ecosystems and the writhing mass of droid apps most different? 1) The apps do not interact with one another as to exploit energy between apps (no energy flow within app market); 2) They do not reproduce; 3) They do not evolve through the same type of processes; 4) few apps really go extinct.
Let’s explore these in more depth. The applications do not interact with each other. There is only competition between apps for the attention and download by the consumer. Because of this, the “energy” flow is very shallow. To be honest, there is some monetary energy flow through the advertising that likely deepens the energy flow, but again the competition is between apps for the consumer’s download so that the most successful apps will receive more monetary “energy” from outside their cyber-world. A true ecosystem needs the constitutent units to interact with one another in the process of exploiting energy trapped within other units.
Apps don’t reproduce unless they are malicious. And frankly, these are the closest programs to living organisms, but that is a discussion for another day. New apps come to the market through the hand of human creators, not through biotic-style genetic-based evolutionary processes.
The rapid developement of new apps to the ever-changing world of consumer whims does not follow biotic evolutionary models of species survival and extinction, but that is fine since very few other properties of the App market follow real ecosystems either. On a little aside, each app should be considered a new species if the app market were to be painted as an ecosystem, because there are fairly large differences in programming even between similar apps.
Finally, very few apps actually go extinct. Within the biologic world when an organism or species go extinct their bodies decay and hopefully become fossils, but in most cases their energy is no longer available for exploitation. (Fossil fuels are an obvious exception to the rule.) Droid apps on the other hand simply sit in the market place taking up space or they lie around on the internet waiting to be downloaded again as long as someone leaves them there. In fact one could consider the droid market to be a giant demolition derby with the wreckage of other failed apps clogging up the cyber space for those still driving. If there is a great change in consumer’s wants and they decide to download some early version of a pac-man app, that app will likely still be around if just in a state of suspended animation. Wait!!! you say, apps are just a new type of organism. Well, I thought of that too. And no they are not, here is why.
Bottom line of this post is that Android apps do not live in an ecosystem. They live in a highly active ECONOMIC system. Applications are simple human produced artisan crafts for sale within a digital platform. Nothing more.
I applaud the marketing genius that first started using Android Ecosystem because it places an image of apps interacting, lion apps eating buffalo apps. But that is simply not the case. To me, it is just as exciting to celebrate the creativity of humans by telling the truth about the app market, calling it the Android SAFE (Supreme Application Free Enterprise).